Robert Lyman – Background and Experience

Contributed by Robert Lyman © 2019

Robert Lyman

As a frequent contributor to Friends of Science Society reports and blog posts and as a guest speaker at the 2017 annual event, I have usually presented my biography in simple terms, that I worked in the public service for 27 years and was a diplomat for 10 years prior to that.  However, people have requested more information about my experience and with what authority do I write on the energy and environmental policy issues.  I prepared this overview.

 

In a nutshell, I have spent over forty years as an economist, manager and consultant working on a broad range of energy and environment public policy issues, mainly for the Canadian federal government. The following is a point form summary of my experience.

 

 

  • After graduation with an Honours degree in International Relations (Economics, Political Science and History), I joined the former federal Department of External Affairs. I served as a Canadian diplomat for ten years, with postings in Caracas, Venezuela and Washington, D.C.
  • My assignment in Washington occurred during a period when both Canada and the U.S. were heavily regulating oil and natural gas markets and prices, and there were several outstanding issues to be resolved concerning cross-border oil and gas trade and pipelines, including whether the MacKenzie Valley Pipeline should be built. This gave me an opportunity to learn a great deal about energy and trade regulation and pricing issues.
  • After leaving the foreign service, I worked as an economist in the Energy Policy Branch of the Energy, Mines and Resources department during the acrimonious negotiations over oil and gas policy before and after the publication of the National Energy Program.
  • I worked for two years in Finance Canada analyzing and advising on energy expenditure issues related to the federal Budget.
  • After that, I led a group of economists responsible for analysis of international oil prices and market conditions.
  • For two years, I worked on Executive Interchange as the Ottawa representative of the Canadian Gas Association at the time of natural gas deregulation.
  • In the late 1980s, I was the Senior Director of Energy Policy when climate change issues first arose; I was heavily engaged at that time in implementation of the Offshore Accords with Newfoundland and Nova Scotia and with the negotiation of the resource aspects of aboriginal land claims.
  • I was the first federal co-chair of the Federal-Provincial Committee on Climate Change.
  • I was the Senior Director of Oil Policy from 1995 to 2002 when the fiscal regime governing oil sands development was being expanded, and I worked closely with Finance Canada on the key issues. At that time, I led the first federal work assessing the public policy that should govern carbon dioxide capture and geological storage.
  • I managed the group providing expert advice on the potential for emissions reduction in the oil industry during the Climate Change Table Process prior to the Kyoto Accord.
  • I was the Director General, Environmental Affairs, in Transport Canada from 2002 to 2006, leading the analysis and policy development with respect to emissions reduction in the transport sector, development and implementation of climate programs, and promotion of technology development to reduce emissions in the transport sector.
  • As a consultant from 2006 on, I performed major studies for Transport Canada on the implementation of the new Navigable Waters Protection Act, on the governance of the offshore oil shipping regime and on the development of a seamless regulatory regime to govern the prevention of and response to ship-source oil spills.
  • I have written extensively on energy and climate-related issues, including several articles for the FOSS and a major paper on the factors affecting energy transitions for the U.K. Global Warming Policy Foundation.
  • Throughout my public service career, I worked for eight Prime Ministers: Pierre Trudeau, Joe Clark, John Turner, Brian Mulroney, Kim Campbell, Jean Chretien, Paul Martin and Stephen Harper. I was proud to perform my public service duties in a non-partisan way.

~~~~

Can Canada Survive Climate Change Policy?

 

Text of address:

Can Canada Survive Climate Change Policy?

3 Comments

  1. James Strachan

    i really like the effort to get something simple about cost so that the average citizen can understand. I note and appreciate the effort to itemize all the cost factors. Brainstorming: might you suggest optimistic/likely/pessimistic annual cost per househoold of the current policy and project forward — and compare to USA?

  2. Alan Tomalty (@ATomalty)

    I have read Robert Lyman’s treatise on “When climate prophecy fails”, I agree with his points. However he does not understand that TRANSIENT CLIMATE RESPONSE TO EMISSIONS ia bogus statistic Here is the link that completely debunks the IPCC use of the term. https://tambonthongchai.com/2018/05/06/tcre/ it has no validity either in measuring temperature change nor in measuring much of anything. How could it when the atmosphere is an open system with sources and sinks of CO2?

  3. Colin

    Friends of Science need to learn some basic physics.
    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radiative_forcing

146 Pingbacks

  1. The Canadian Climate Policy Numbers Game | Friends of Science Calgary
  2. Squandered Money : Funding Mass Transit to Reduce Emissions | Friends of Science Calgary
  3. Teck-Public Interest Betrayed? | Friends of Science Calgary
  4. Prosperity Foregone – A Summary | Friends of Science Calgary
  5. Avi Lewis-In the Dark on RE | Friends of Science Calgary
  6. NetZero Canada-Benefits? | Friends of Science Calgary
  7. Quebec - Climate Impossible | Friends of Science Calgary
  8. Biting the Hand that Feeds You | Friends of Science Calgary
  9. Mayday-Aviation Climate Policy | Friends of Science Calgary
  10. Inconvenient Facts | Friends of Science Calgary
  11. Empty Wallets-Renewables | Friends of Science Calgary
  12. Grid Scale Battery Debunked | Friends of Science Calgary
  13. Empty Pockets Clean Tech | Friends of Science Calgary
  14. The "Net Zero" Emissions Myth | Friends of Science Calgary
  15. Liz May - No 100% RE by 2030 | Friends of Science Calgary
  16. Litigating Climate Change | Friends of Science Calgary
  17. Climate Pancake Policies | Friends of Science Calgary
  18. Won't Die from Climate Change | Friends of Science Calgary
  19. Wake UP: Andrew Leach Oil Sands | Friends of Science Calgary
  20. Adaptation vs Mitigation | Friends of Science Calgary
  21. Futile Folly on Climate | Friends of Science Calgary
  22. Dark Cloud Conflict of Interest | Friends of Science Calgary
  23. Cdn Charities-More Public Funds | Friends of Science Calgary
  24. Retract U of A Wind Farm Report | Friends of Science Calgary
  25. Stranded Assets are a Myth | Friends of Science Calgary
  26. Offshore Wind-High Risk | Friends of Science Calgary
  27. Defence of Affordable Housing | Friends of Science Calgary
  28. Dems Climate Plans Costly | Friends of Science Calgary
  29. Money for Nothing-EV Buses | Friends of Science Calgary
  30. Paris Gap - Pitfall for Canada | Friends of Science Calgary
  31. Shell's Guilt Trip | Friends of Science Calgary
  32. IEA -Inconvenient Facts | Friends of Science Calgary
  33. Exposing the EV Fantasy: The Real Cost of EV's | | Climate- Science.press
  34. Exposing the EV Fantasy | Friends of Science Calgary
  35. Assessing the Alleged Benefits of EV's: Exposing the Fantasy – Part 2 | | Climate- Science.press
  36. FALSE EXPECTATIONS: The Electric Vehicle Fantasy – Part 3 – Climate- Science.press
  37. Alleged Benefits of EV's | Friends of Science Calgary
  38. Cash in on Climate | Friends of Science Calgary
  39. A Landscape Littered with Climate Cash – Climate- Science.press
  40. Climate Finance Never Enough | Friends of Science Calgary
  41. Bill C-12 For Net Zero By 2050 – Legislating The Impossible Dream? – Climate- Science.press
  42. Bill C-12 Impossible Dream | Friends of Science Calgary
  43. Dirty Lies About Oil Sands Crude: Clearing the Air on Carbon Intensity – Climate- Science.press
  44. The Simple Truth: Where Climate Policy is Taking Canada – Climate- Science.press
  45. Climate Policy Destroys Canada | Friends of Science Calgary
  46. When Giants Arise | Friends of Science Calgary
  47. WHEN GIANTS ARISE: The Real World of GHG Emissions and Growth – Climate- Science.press
  48. Pick Your Poison on Climate Policy vs Effective Management of Economy and Tax Dollars – Climate- Science.press
  49. Storm in Glasgow for COP26 | Friends of Science Calgary
  50. Storm Signals for COP 26 in Glasgow – Climate- Science.press
  51. Is Climate Change Real? | Friends of Science Calgary
  52. Is Climate Change Real? – Climate- Science.press
  53. IEA Oil Markets to 2026 | Friends of Science Calgary
  54. International Energy Agency Oil Market Forecast to 2026: Slow Growth, But More Bad News for Climate Alarm – Climate- Science.press
  55. A Cruel and Unusual Punishment – NetZero2050 Climate Policy – Climate- Science.press
  56. Cruel and Unusual Punishment | Friends of Science Calgary
  57. Climate Adaptation Uncertainty | Friends of Science Calgary
  58. Climate Adaptation – A Better Response to Uncertainty? – Climate- Science.press
  59. Near-Term Energy Future Facts | Friends of Science Calgary
  60. HoC Briefs on Green Economy | Friends of Science Calgary
  61. The Role of the Green Economy in Pandemic Recovery – Climate- Science.press
  62. EXXON - A Green Win in Court? | Friends of Science Calgary
  63. Magical Thinking - Net Zero | Friends of Science Calgary
  64. Magical Thinking – Why “Net Zero” Is Neither Possible nor Desirable – Climate- Science.press
  65. Hazards Ahead on NetZero | Friends of Science Calgary
  66. WHAT ENERGY TRANSITION? | Friends of Science Calgary
  67. WHAT ENERGY TRANSITION? – Climate- Science.press
  68. Ottawa’s Climate Policy Vision: A Plan to Give The People What They Don’t Want | Friends of Science Calgary
  69. Debunking The Scare Tactics – More Evidence That IPCC Models Are Flawed | Friends of Science Calgary
  70. Debunking The Scare Tactics – More Evidence That IPCC Models Are Flawed – Climate- Science.press
  71. COP26 Climate Conference in Glasgow – Show Me the Money! – Climate- Science.press
  72. Net Zero 2050? Not What the Experts Predict. | Friends of Science Calgary
  73. Net Zero 2050? Not What the Experts Predict. – Climate- Science.press
  74. Will We Squander Canada’s Energy Resource Heritage? | Friends of Science Calgary
  75. Carbon Dioxide Capture and Storage and Oil Sands | Friends of Science Calgary
  76. Carbon Dioxide Capture and Storage and Oil Sands – Climate- Science.press
  77. The Theatre of The Absurd | Friends of Science Calgary
  78. COP26 NetZero Climate Goals are More Aspirational Than Real – Climate- Science.press
  79. Ressources naturelles Canada – Faits dérangeants pour les militants du climat | Friends of Science Calgary
  80. THE CARBON CAPTURE AND STORAGE TRAP For taxpayers. | Friends of Science Calgary
  81. Grocery Bill Shock: Starve the Poor to “Save the Planet”? | Friends of Science Calgary
  82. Grocery Bill Shock: Starve the Poor to “Save the Planet”? - Climate- Science.press
  83. How Will Climate Change Affect World Income? | Friends of Science Calgary
  84. BP Statistical Review – The Tales Told By Numbers | Friends of Science Calgary
  85. BP Statistical Review – The Tales Told by Numbers - Climate- Science.press
  86. Energy Security – The Unique Problems of Wind and Solar Energy | Friends of Science Calgary
  87. Ottawa’s War on Drivers, Homeowners and Business | Friends of Science Calgary
  88. Canada’s Environment –The Amazing Untold Success Story | Friends of Science Calgary
  89. THE IPCC – Analyst or Advocate? | Friends of Science Calgary
  90. Canada’s Hydrogen Policy Fiasco – Costs and Expectations are Out of This World | Friends of Science Calgary
  91. Canada’s Hydrogen Policy Fiasco – Costs and Expectations are Out of This World - Climate- Science.press
  92. COP27 – It’s All About the Money | Friends of Science Calgary
  93. COP27 – It’s All About the Money - Climate- Science.press
  94. TECHNOLOGY DREAMING: At last- The Flying Car! | Friends of Science Calgary
  95. TECHNOLOGY DREAMING: At last- The Flying Car! - Climate- Science.press
  96. COP 27 – The Show Goes On | Friends of Science Calgary
  97. COP 27 – The Show Goes On - Climate- Science.press
  98. THE UNSTOPPABLE GROWTH OF GLOBAL GHG EMISSIONS – Greening the Planet; Conning the Public | Friends of Science Calgary
  99. THE UNSTOPPABLE GROWTH OF GLOBAL GHG EMISSIONS – Greening the Planet; Conning the Public - Climate- Science.press
  100. Too Far. Too Fast. NetZero 2030 and the Hubris of Proposed Carbon-Pricing Legislation. | Friends of Science Calgary
  101. Too Far. Too Fast. NetZero 2030 and the Hubris of Proposed Carbon-Pricing Legislation. - Climate- Science.press
  102. Electrify Everything – Then What? | Friends of Science Calgary
  103. COP 27- What Really Happened, What Did Not | Friends of Science Calgary
  104. Electrify Everything – Then What? - Climate- Science.press
  105. COP 27- What Really Happened, What Did Not - Climate- Science.press
  106. THE PURSUIT OF THE IMPOSSIBLEMaterials Constraints and Realities for the Net Zero Utopia | Friends of Science Calgary
  107. THE PURSUIT OF THE IMPOSSIBLE Materials Constraints and Realities for the Net Zero Utopia - Climate- Science.press
  108. THE EXPRESS BUS TO FOLLY: EV Bus Plans Challenged By Canadian Climate, Costs and Declining Ridership | Friends of Science Calgary
  109. Trade Protectionism Turns “Green”: Europe’s New Colonialism – Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism | Friends of Science Calgary
  110. The World In 2045 According to OPEC | Friends of Science Calgary
  111. CANADA’S 2030 EMISSIONS REDUCTION PLAN: PART 1 – Killing The Canadian Golden Geese | Friends of Science Calgary
  112. BETWEEN THE IMPLAUSIBLE AND IMPOSSIBLE: The Misused Scenario Driving Climate Emergency Policies | Friends of Science Calgary
  113. The Corruption of Climate Science: how was it done? – UK Reloaded
  114. The Market That Refuses to Conform | Friends of Science Calgary
  115. The Climate Elements in Canada’s Budget 2023: Just The Facts | Friends of Science Calgary
  116. Making Sense of Canada’s 2023 Federal Government Budget | Friends of Science Calgary
  117. Mining Of Cobalt for Electric Vehicle Batteries: THE SOCIAL IMPACTS | Friends of Science Calgary
  118. Mining Of Cobalt for Electric Vehicle Batteries: THE SOCIAL IMPACTS - Climate- Science.press
  119. Canada – The Climate Pawn | Friends of Science Calgary
  120. Canada – The Climate Pawn - Climate- Science.press
  121. Not Worth the Money – The Costs and Benefits Of Global Climate Policies | Friends of Science Calgary
  122. Not Worth the Money – The Costs and Benefits Of Global Climate Policies - Climate- Science.press
  123. How To Present “Up” As “Down” – The IEA Medium-Term Oil Market Report | Friends of Science Calgary
  124. WHEN THE FACTS COLLIDE WITH CLIMATE ALARM | Friends of Science Calgary
  125. How To Present “Up” As “Down” – The IEA Medium-Term Oil Market Report - Climate- Science.press
  126. A Cornucopia of Bad Ideas: Climate Finance for Loss and Damage in the Leadup to COP28 | Friends of Science Calgary
  127. WHEN THE FACTS COLLIDE WITH CLIMATE ALARM - Climate- Science.press
  128. FLYING BLIND – EUROPE’S PLANS TO DECARBONIZE AVIATION | Friends of Science Calgary
  129. A Cornucopia of Bad Ideas: Climate Finance for Loss and Damage in the Leadup to COP28 - Climate- Science.press
  130. The “Climate Denier” Insult Is An Appeal To Ignorance | Friends of Science Calgary
  131. Let’s Not Pursue “Peak Oil” – The Risks to Society of a Global Oil Shortfall Due to Climate Fear | Friends of Science Calgary
  132. Let’s Not Pursue “Peak Oil” – The Risks to Society of a Global Oil Shortfall Due to Climate Fear - Climate- Science.press
  133. “Climate Data” Meant to Mislead | Friends of Science Calgary
  134. “Climate Data” Meant to Mislead - Climate- Science.press
  135. When Will Climate Policy Hit the Wall? Text of Robert Lyman’s Presentation. - Climate- Science.press
  136. COP28 Dystopia: The Effort to Phase-Out Fossil Fuel Production | Friends of Science Calgary
  137. THE CARBON TAX – IT’S JUST NOT FAIR | Friends of Science Calgary
  138. Outcome Of COP 28 – Just The Facts | Friends of Science Calgary
  139. Nova Scotia Turns Its Back On Economic Development | Friends of Science Calgary
  140. Nova Scotia Turns Its Back On Economic Development - Climate- Science.press
  141. A STUDY IN CONTRASTS: Canada ‘doubles down’ on self-destruction | Friends of Science Calgary
  142. SS Canada: Off Course and Headed for Icebergs | Friends of Science Calgary
  143. SS Canada: Off Course and Headed for Icebergs - Climate- Science.press
  144. Confronting The Fear Of Climate Disasters | Friends of Science Calgary
  145. Confronting The Fear Of Climate Disasters - Climate- Science.press
  146. Smoke and Mirrors: My Model Can Beat Up Your Model | Friends of Science Calgary

Leave a Reply! Please be courteous and respectful; profanity will not be tolerated.


Privacy Policy Cookies Policy
©2002-2024 Friends of Science Society
Friends of Science Calgary